Consent: vocabulary and concepts · Reference
Glossary
The course's terms and their sources. Lessons use these terms exactly as defined here. Grounded in California law, not legal advice.
The five tests
A yes is valid consent only if it passes all five. Introduced in Lesson 1.
- Capacity
- The ability to consent at all. Missing if the person is under the age of consent, asleep, unconscious, incapacitated, or unable to communicate.Ed. Code 67386; Penal Code 261.5
- Voluntary (freely given)
- The choice is made without force, threats, pressure, or abuse of trust. Penal Code 261.6 calls this "an exercise of free will." Civil Code 1565 calls contract consent "free."Penal Code 261.6; Civil Code 1565
- Informed
- The person has "knowledge of the nature of the act." Lies or concealment about the act defeat it.Penal Code 261.6; Planned Parenthood FRIES
- Expressed (communicated)
- The yes is actually communicated. Silence, lack of resistance, and a dating or marital relationship are not consent.Ed. Code 67386; Penal Code 261.6; Civil Code 1565
- Specific
- A yes covers one act, with one person, at one time. It must be ongoing and can be withdrawn at any time.Ed. Code 67386; Planned Parenthood FRIES
Standards and definitions
- Consent (California criminal law)
- "Positive cooperation in act or attitude pursuant to an exercise of free will."Penal Code 261.6
- Affirmative consent
- "Affirmative, conscious, and voluntary agreement to engage in sexual activity." Also called "yes means yes."Ed. Code 67386
- Inferred consent
- Consent read from behavior, "both action and inaction," in context. This is the 2022 Model Penal Code position, which rejected the affirmative standard.MPC 213.0(2)(e)(ii) (2022)
- Willingness vs agreement
- Willingness is a state of mind that others infer (Model Penal Code). Agreement is something communicated (California). "She was willing" and "she agreed" make different claims.MPC 213.0(2)(e)(i); Ed. Code 67386(a)(1)
- Enthusiastic consent
- Going ahead only when the other person actually wants the act, not only agrees to it. An ethical and educational standard, not a legal test in US law.Planned Parenthood FRIES; Bennett, Alternative Law Journal (2024)
- Acquiescence (submission)
- Going along without objecting. Under the Model Penal Code, submission or acquiescence is not effective consent when produced by force, threats, or other listed circumstances.MPC 213.1(3) and parallel sections
- Marital exemption
- The historic rule that a husband could not rape his wife. Written into the 1962 Model Penal Code ("a female not his wife"). California made spousal rape a crime in 1979 and merged it into the general rape statute in 2021.Wikipedia: Marital rape in the United States
- FRIES
- Planned Parenthood's plain-language checklist: Freely given, Reversible, Informed, Enthusiastic, Specific.Planned Parenthood
- Revocable (reversible)
- Consent can be withdrawn at any time, including partway through.Ed. Code 67386
- Incapacitation
- So affected by drugs, alcohol, or medication that the person "could not understand the fact, nature, or extent of the sexual activity." Being intoxicated is not, by itself, being incapacitated. Asleep, unconscious, and unable to communicate due to a mental or physical condition are listed separately.Ed. Code 67386(a)(4)
- Age of consent
- 18 in California. A minor's willing participation is not legal consent.Penal Code 261.5
The five standards
What counts as a yes at all. Introduced in Lesson 2. The names are this course's labels.
| Standard | Core rule | Silence counts? | Source |
|---|---|---|---|
| Force | A crime needs force or threats | Yes, absent force | MPC (1962) |
| Refusal ("no means no") | A clear no ends consent | Yes, until a no | MPC 213.0(2)(e)(iv) |
| Inferred | Willingness read from behavior | Sometimes | MPC 213.0(2)(e)(ii) |
| Affirmative ("yes means yes") | Each person ensures the other agreed | No | Ed. Code 67386(a)(1) |
| Enthusiastic | Only what the other person wants | No | Planned Parenthood FRIES |
Pressure words
Ways of getting a yes that does not count. Introduced in Lesson 3. Under Civil Code 1567, contract consent obtained through duress, menace, fraud, undue influence, or mistake is "not real or free."
- Coercion
- The umbrella word for getting compliance through pressure. Prefer a more precise term below when one fits.
- Force
- Physical compulsion. Penal Code 261(a)(2) lists "force, violence, duress, menace, or fear of immediate and unlawful bodily injury." Fails Voluntary.Penal Code 261(a)(2)
- Duress (civil)
- Unlawful confinement of the person or their close family, or unlawful detention of their property. Fails Voluntary.Civil Code 1569
- Duress (criminal)
- "A direct or implied threat of force, violence, danger, or retribution sufficient to coerce a reasonable person of ordinary susceptibilities." The victim's age and relationship to the defendant are factors. Fails Voluntary.Penal Code 261(b)
- Menace (civil)
- A threat of duress, of unlawful and violent injury, or "of injury to the character" of the person. Fails Voluntary.Civil Code 1570
- Menace (criminal)
- "Any threat, declaration, or act that shows an intention to inflict an injury upon another." Fails Voluntary.Penal Code 261(b)
- Extortion
- The Model Penal Code's term for sex obtained by threats to accuse someone of a crime, to use official power, or any threat that would make "someone of ordinary resolution" submit. California separately names threats "to incarcerate, arrest, or deport." Fails Voluntary.MPC 213.4; Penal Code 261(a)(7)
- Undue influence
- Using a position of trust or authority, someone's "weakness of mind," or their distress to gain an unfair advantage. No threat is needed. Fails Voluntary.Civil Code 1575
- Sexual coercion
- "Unwanted sexual activity that happens when you are pressured, tricked, threatened, or forced in a nonphysical way." Examples include repeated asking and threats to end the relationship. Often not a crime by itself. Fails Voluntary.US Office on Women's Health
- Coercive control
- "A pattern of behavior that in purpose or effect unreasonably interferes with a person's free will and personal liberty." Examples include isolation, deprivation, monitoring, threats, and reproductive coercion. It describes a pattern, not a single act. Defined in domestic violence restraining-order law.Family Code 6320(c)
- Fraud
- Deception that produces the yes. Fails Informed.Civil Code 1567
- Impersonation
- Making someone believe you are another person they know. The main sexual deception that criminal law covers.Penal Code 261(a)(5); MPC 213.5
- Mistake
- A misunderstanding that produces the yes. Fails Informed.Civil Code 1567
Capacity
Four ways the law removes capacity. Introduced in Lesson 4. The category names are this course's labels.
- Age
- Under 18 in California, a person cannot legally consent to sex. A minor's contracts are voidable: the minor may disaffirm them.Penal Code 261.5; Family Code 6710
- State (temporary)
- Asleep, unconscious, passing in and out of consciousness, or incapacitated by drugs, alcohol, or medication.Ed. Code 67386(a)(4); MPC 213.3
- Intoxication vs incapacitation
- Incapacitation is "a state beyond drunkenness or intoxication." The test is whether the person could "understand the fact, nature, or extent of the sexual activity." Being intoxicated yourself does not excuse a mistaken belief in consent.UC SVSH Policy; Ed. Code 67386(a)(2), (a)(4)(B)
- Condition (ongoing)
- A mental disorder or developmental or physical disability that leaves a person unable to understand the nature of the act or to act freely. The test is understanding, not diagnosis.Penal Code 261(a)(1), (b)
- Position
- Relationships where the law says consent is no defense: staff and confined persons or parolees, psychotherapists (including MFTs) and clients.Penal Code 289.6; Bus. & Prof. Code 728, 729; MPC 213.3(3)
- Void
- Never had legal effect. Example: a contract by "a person entirely without understanding."Civil Code 38
- Voidable
- Valid unless the protected person cancels it (rescission or disaffirmance). Examples: a minor's contract, a contract by a person of unsound mind, consent obtained by duress.Family Code 6710; Civil Code 39, 1566
Consent over time
Introduced in Lesson 5.
- Sexual precedent
- The belief that consensual sex once implies consent to later sex with the same person. Research finds people report fewer consent cues as shared history grows. The law rejects it: past sexual relations are never by themselves consent.Willis & Jozkowski (2019); Ed. Code 67386(a)(1); Penal Code 261.6
- Invitation
- Speech that opens a sexual possibility the other person is free to take or leave. One of the speech acts Kukla says matters more than consent alone.Kukla, Ethics (2018)
- Check-in
- A question partway through that renews consent ("Still good?"). This course's term for keeping consent ongoing.Ed. Code 67386(a)(1), "ongoing"
- Exit condition
- An agreement in advance on how to stop, such as a safeword.Kukla, Ethics (2018)
- Explicit prior permission
- A Model Penal Code defense for agreed rough sex. The permission must be given orally or in writing and must stipulate "the specific words or gestures that will withdraw the permission." Nonverbal signals do not qualify.MPC 213.10