Consent: vocabulary and conceptsLesson 2about 15 minutes

Five standards of consent

Lesson 1 asked whether a yes is valid. This lesson asks a prior question: what counts as a yes at all? Five standards answer it differently. The fastest way to tell them apart is to ask what each one does with silence.

Warm-up

Score: 0 / 0 · 0 of 3 answered

Questions from Lesson 1. Answer from memory before reading on. Which of the five tests fails?

  1. A tenant signs after the landlord lies about what the lease change does.

  2. Halfway through, one partner says "stop." The other keeps going because the first partner agreed earlier.

  3. A partner is asleep.

The five standards

StandardCore ruleSilence counts as consent?
ForceA crime needs force or threats. Lack of consent alone is not enough.Yes, unless force was used
Refusal ("no means no")A clear no ends consent.Yes, until someone says no
InferredConsent is willingness, read from behavior in context.Sometimes, depending on circumstances
Affirmative ("yes means yes")Each person must make sure the other agreed.No
EnthusiasticGo ahead only when the other person actually wants it.No, and a reluctant yes falls short too

These five names are this course's labels. The sources below use their own terms.

Force

The 1962 Model Penal Code began: "A male who has sexual intercourse with a female not his wife is guilty of rape if..." and then required force or serious threats (Wikipedia summary). That one sentence carries two old ideas. Force, not lack of consent, defined the crime. And marriage was an exemption. California made spousal rape a crime in 1979 and kept it as a separate statute until 2021.

Refusal

"No means no" puts the duty on the person who does not want sex: they must refuse. The 2022 Model Penal Code keeps a refusal rule inside its larger definition: "A clear verbal refusal—such as 'No,' 'Stop,' or 'Don't'—establishes the lack of consent" (MPC 213.0(2)(e)(iv)). Under MPC 213.6, sex after someone "expressly communicated unwillingness" is graded as a more serious felony than sex without consent alone.

Inferred

The 2022 Model Penal Code defines consent as "a person's willingness to engage in a specific act." It "may be express or it may be inferred from behavior—both action and inaction—in the context of all the circumstances" (MPC 213.0(2)(e)(i)-(ii)). The American Law Institute considered an affirmative standard and rejected it (ALI Adviser).

Affirmative

California's campus standard is "affirmative, conscious, and voluntary agreement." It puts the duty on the person seeking sex: "It is the responsibility of each person involved... to ensure that the person has the affirmative consent of the other." Silence and lack of resistance do not count (Ed. Code 67386(a)(1)). The statute requires agreement. It does not require that agreement be spoken.

Enthusiastic

Planned Parenthood's FRIES says to "only do stuff you WANT to do, not things that you feel you're expected to do" (Planned Parenthood). No US law uses this as its legal test. Theodore Bennett argues it should not become a legal standard but keeps its value in education and ethics (Bennett, Alternative Law Journal, 2024). Some scholars go further and argue that consent of any kind sets too low a bar for good sex. Lesson 5 returns to that.

Willingness vs agreement. This is the one distinction to carry into editing. Willingness (Model Penal Code) is a state of mind that someone else infers. Agreement (California) is something communicated. "She was willing" describes what someone believed about her. "She agreed" describes what she did.

Scenarios: reading a manuscript

editing

"She didn't stop him."

This sentence satisfies only the Refusal standard. Under the Affirmative standard it shows no consent at all. If the author means the scene to be consensual, the sentence undercuts that. If the author means it to be non-consensual, the sentence is accurate but may read as ambiguous.

editing

"She went along with it."

This describes acquiescence. The Model Penal Code says "submission, acquiescence, or words or conduct that would otherwise indicate consent" are not effective consent when obtained by force, threats, or other listed circumstances (e.g., MPC 213.1(3)). A reader may read "went along with" as pressure.

conversation

Your partner says "I guess, sure" in a flat voice.

Under the Affirmative standard that may be agreement. Under the Enthusiastic standard it is a signal to pause: "That sounded like a maybe. We can do something else."

Quiz

Score: 0 / 0 · 0 of 7 answered

Which standard is described?

  1. Consent is willingness, and it can be read from inaction in context.

  2. Each person is responsible for making sure the other has agreed.

  3. Without force or serious threats, there is no crime.

  4. A free but reluctant "okay" is not enough.

  5. Consent stands until someone says no.

  6. Editing check. Which word reports something the character communicated?

  7. Editing check. What does "She went along with it" describe?

Read the Model Penal Code consent definition next to Ed. Code 67386(a)(1). The MPC excerpt and the Ed. Code copy are each short. Read for one thing: which words each uses for consent, and who has to act.

Reference: Glossary, now with the five standards.

Your answers are saved only in this browser, so you can pick up where you left off.