Consent: vocabulary and concepts · Reference

Cheat sheet

Five tests of valid consent (L1)

TestAskFails when
CapacityAble to consent at all?Age, asleep, incapacitated, condition, position
VoluntaryFree choice?Force, threats, abuse of trust, wearing down
InformedKnows what they agreed to?Fraud, impersonation, mistake
ExpressedActually said or showed yes?Silence, no resistance, relationship assumed
SpecificThis act, now?Yes stretched to another act, withdrawal ignored

Five standards: what counts as yes (L2)

StandardRuleSilence counts?Source
ForceCrime needs force or threatsYes, absent forceMPC 1962
RefusalA clear no ends consentYes, until a noMPC 213.0(2)(e)(iv)
InferredWillingness read from behaviorSometimesMPC 213.0(2)(e)(ii)
AffirmativeEach person ensures agreementNoEd. Code 67386(a)(1)
EnthusiasticOnly what they wantNoFRIES (ethical, not legal)

Willingness is a state of mind someone else infers. Agreement is something communicated. "She was willing" and "she agreed" make different claims.

Pressure words, by how the pressure works (L3)

MechanismTermsFails
Physicalforce, violence, restraintVoluntary
Threatduress, menace, extortionVoluntary
Positionundue influenceVoluntary
Wearing downsexual coercion (act), coercive control (pattern)Voluntary
Deceptionfraud, impersonation, mistakeInformed

Duress means unlawful confinement in civil law (Civ. 1569) and a threat that would coerce a reasonable person in criminal law (PC 261(b)). Check which meaning is intended.

Capacity: four ways it fails (L4)

CategoryExamplesSource
AgeUnder 18PC 261.5
StateAsleep, unconscious, incapacitatedEd. Code 67386(a)(4)
ConditionDisability that prevents understandingPC 261(a)(1)
PositionConfined person and staff, client and therapist: consent is no defensePC 289.6; B&P 729

Intoxicated is not incapacitated. The test is whether they could understand "the fact, nature, or extent" of the act. Void means it never had effect. Voidable means it stands unless the protected person cancels it.

Consent over time (L5)

TermMeaningSay
Sexual precedentPast sex treated as future consent. The law rejects it.-
InvitationOpens a possibility the other person is free to decline"I'd love to, if you would too."
Check-inRenews consent partway through"Still good?"
Exit conditionAgreed in advance on how to stop"If you say 'pause,' I stop."