Consent: vocabulary and conceptsLesson 5about 15 minutes

Consent over time

The law says history is not consent. Research shows that people in long relationships act as if it is. This lesson covers that gap and the language for closing it: invitations, check-ins, and exit conditions.

Warm-up

Score: 0 / 0 · 0 of 3 answered

Questions from Lessons 1 to 3. Answer from memory.

  1. "We've been married ten years" is offered as proof of consent. Which test does that confuse?

  2. Under which standard does silence count until someone objects?

  3. Ongoing monitoring, isolation, and control of money. What is the term?

The precedent problem

California law is clear. "The existence of a dating relationship... or the fact of past sexual relations... should never by itself be assumed to be an indicator of consent" (Ed. Code 67386(a)(1)). A "current or previous dating or marital relationship shall not be sufficient to constitute consent" (Penal Code 261.6).

People don't behave that way. Researchers call the belief sexual precedent: having had consensual sex once implies consent later. Malachi Willis and Kristen Jozkowski found that as the number of past sexual encounters with a partner rose, people reported fewer consent cues. They conclude that consent "cannot be assumed even after previous sexual encounters" (Willis & Jozkowski, Archives of Sexual Behavior, 2019).

An earlier study gave 414 undergraduates a scene where consent was ambiguous. Only the couple's history changed: a first date, three months of dating, or two years of marriage. The longer the history, the more consensual, acceptable, and clear readers judged the same ambiguous scene. Men rated every version as more consensual than women did (Humphreys, Journal of Sex Research, 2007).

For editing. Readers already lean toward reading a long marriage as consent. A manuscript that wants a long-married couple's consent to be clear has to show it on the page. One that leaves it unstated will often be read as consensual, whether or not the author meant that.

Beyond yes and no

Quill R. Kukla (published in 2018 as Rebecca Kukla) argues that the focus on consent "has distorted our understanding of sexual agency and ethics." Good sexual negotiation relies on more kinds of speech than asking and answering. It also uses "sexual invitations and gift offers, as well as speech designed to set up safe frameworks and exit conditions." Good communication does more than prevent harm: "it enables forms of agency, pleasure, and fulfillment that would not otherwise be possible" (Kukla, Ethics, 2018). This is the "consent sets too low a bar" view mentioned in Lesson 2.

Speech actWhat it doesExample
InvitationOpens a possibility that the other person is free to take or leave"I'd love to stay over, if you'd like that too."
Check-inRenews consent partway through, which keeps it Specific and ongoing"Still feel good?"
Exit conditionAgrees in advance on how to stop"If either of us says 'pause,' we stop. No questions."

"Check-in" is this course's term. Invitation and exit condition are Kukla's.

The Model Penal Code also recognizes exit conditions. Its defense of explicit prior permission for agreed rough sex applies only if the permission was given orally or in writing and stipulated "the specific words or gestures that will withdraw the permission." Nonverbal signals do not qualify (MPC 213.10, in the full official text).

Scenarios

relational

After 25 years, Pat reaches for Lee in bed every Sunday morning without a word. Lee usually welcomes it. This Sunday Lee is grieving and goes still.

Sexual precedent. The routine has replaced the cues. Lee's stillness is "lack of protest," which is not consent. A check-in would catch it: "Not today?"

relational

A couple agrees that "yellow" means slow down and "red" means stop.

Exit condition. This makes withdrawal easy and unambiguous, which is the Specific test made practical.

editing

Manuscript: "After all these years, he knew what she wanted without asking."

This presents precedent as knowledge. If the author means it as a picture of intimacy, a reader who knows the research may read it as a missing check-in. One option: "After all these years, he still asked, and she loved that he did."

Saying it in a long relationship

MomentSay
Inviting"I'm in the mood. Are you, or is tonight a no?"
Checking in"Still good?" or "More, or less?"
Setting an exit"If you say 'pause,' I stop, and I won't be hurt."
Receiving a no"Thanks for telling me." Then mean it.
Withdrawing yourself"I want to stop. It's not about you."

These phrasings are suggestions.

Quiz

Score: 0 / 0 · 0 of 6 answered

Which term fits?

  1. "We do this every Saturday, so I didn't ask."

  2. Before starting, they agree that "red" means stop at once.

  3. "I'd love to stay over tonight, if you'd like that too."

  4. Partway through: "Still feel good?"

  5. In Humphreys (2007), as the fictional couple's history grew, readers judged the same ambiguous scene as:

  6. Editing check. Which sentence does not present history as consent?

Quill R. Kukla, Sex Beyond "Yes": Pleasure and Agency for Everyone (Norton, 2025). It is a short book that develops the 2018 article for general readers. For the academic version, read "That's What She Said: The Language of Sexual Negotiation" (Ethics 129, 2018).

Reference: Glossary, now with consent-over-time terms.

Your answers are saved only in this browser, so you can pick up where you left off.