Consent: vocabulary and conceptsLesson 4about 15 minutes
Capacity: who can say yes
Capacity comes before every other test. If a person cannot consent, their yes does not count, however clear or eager it sounds. The law removes capacity in four ways: age, a temporary state, an ongoing condition, and position.
Warm-up
Score: 0 / 0 · 0 of 3 answered
Questions from earlier lessons. Answer from memory.
Four ways capacity fails
| Category | Examples | Key source |
|---|---|---|
| Age | Under 18 in California | Penal Code 261.5 |
| State (temporary) | Asleep, unconscious, incapacitated by drugs or alcohol | Ed. Code 67386(a)(4) |
| Condition (ongoing) | A mental or developmental disability that prevents understanding the act | Penal Code 261(a)(1) |
| Position | Confined person and staff, client and therapist | Penal Code 289.6; Bus. & Prof. Code 729 |
Age
California's age of consent is 18 (Penal Code 261.5). A minor's willing participation does not change that. Contract law treats age differently. A minor's contract "may be disaffirmed by the minor before majority or within a reasonable time afterwards" (Family Code 6710). The contract is not automatically invalid. The minor gets to choose whether to cancel it.
State: intoxicated is not incapacitated
This is the distinction from Lesson 1. The statute's test is not whether someone drank. It is whether they were "incapacitated due to the influence of drugs, alcohol, or medication, so that the complainant could not understand the fact, nature, or extent of the sexual activity" (Ed. Code 67386(a)(4)(B)). The University of California's policy puts it plainly: incapacitation is "a state beyond drunkenness or intoxication," and a person "is not necessarily incapacitated merely as a result of drinking, using drugs, or taking medication" (UC SVSH Policy).
The duty runs the other way too. A belief in consent is no excuse if it "arose from the intoxication or recklessness of the accused," or if the accused did not take "reasonable steps... to ascertain" consent (Ed. Code 67386(a)(2)). Your own drinking does not lower your duty to check. The Model Penal Code adds someone "passing in and out of consciousness" (MPC 213.3(2)(ii)).
Condition
Penal Code 261(a)(1) covers a person "incapable, because of a mental disorder or developmental or physical disability, of giving legal consent." The statute defines that as being unable to understand the nature of the act, or unable to act freely and voluntarily, because of the disability (Penal Code 261). A diagnosis alone does not remove capacity. The question is what the person can understand.
Contract law makes a similar split. "A person entirely without understanding has no power to make a contract of any kind" (Civil Code 38). A contract made by a person "of unsound mind, but not entirely without understanding" can be cancelled through rescission (Civil Code 39). That gives two useful words:
- Void. It never had legal effect. Civil Code 38 is an example.
- Voidable. It is valid unless the protected person cancels it. Civil Code 39 and a minor's contract are examples, as is consent obtained by duress (Civil Code 1566, Lesson 3).
Position: when the law says consent does not count
Some relationships carry so much power that the law ignores the yes entirely. Here the question is not whether this person understood. The law has already decided their consent cannot count.
- Confinement. Staff in detention facilities, public health facilities, and the Department of Corrections and Rehabilitation commit a crime by having sex with a confined adult, an inmate, or a parolee. "Consent by a confined person or parolee... is not a defense" (Penal Code 289.6).
- Therapy. A psychotherapist who has sex with a client, or with a former client when the relationship was ended "primarily for the purpose of" sex, commits sexual exploitation. "In no instance shall consent of the patient or client be a defense" (Bus. & Prof. Code 729). "Psychotherapist" includes marriage and family therapists (Bus. & Prof. Code 728).
The Model Penal Code has a parallel offense for anyone in custody, on probation or parole, or under civil commitment when the other person has authority over that restriction (MPC 213.3(3)).
Scenarios
At a party, Riley has had four drinks. Riley is talking clearly, joking, and asks Sam to leave together. Later Riley is slurring, can't find the door, and doesn't seem to know where they are.
State. Early on, Riley is intoxicated. Later, Riley shows signs that they may not understand "the fact, nature, or extent" of what is happening. If you are unsure, the reasonable step is to wait.
A therapy client tells their therapist they have fallen in love and want a relationship. The client is an adult and sincere.
Position. Under Bus. & Prof. Code 729 the client's consent is no defense. Ending therapy in order to date the client does not cure it either.
A 17-year-old signs a two-year gym contract.
Age. The contract is voidable. The minor can disaffirm it (Family Code 6710).
Saying it in a real conversation
| Moment | Say |
|---|---|
| They've had a lot | "You're pretty drunk. I'd rather wait until tomorrow." |
| You've had a lot | "I've had too much to decide anything tonight." |
| Unsure | "Do you know where we are and what we're doing?" If the answer is unclear, stop. |
These phrasings are suggestions.
Quiz
Score: 0 / 0 · 0 of 8 answered
Which category of capacity applies?
A 16-year-old says an enthusiastic yes.
Age. Under 18 in California (Penal Code 261.5).
A person is passing in and out of consciousness.
State, a temporary one (MPC 213.3(2)(ii)).
A parole agent and the parolee the agent supervises.
Position. Consent "is not a defense" (Penal Code 289.6).
A developmental disability keeps a person from understanding the nature of the act.
Condition. The test is understanding, not diagnosis (Penal Code 261(a)(1)).
A marriage and family therapist and a current client.
Position. Bus. & Prof. Code 729, with MFTs covered under 728.
Someone has been drinking but is following the conversation, speaking clearly, and making choices. They are:
Intoxicated is not incapacitated (UC SVSH Policy). Keep watching, since that can change.
A 17-year-old's gym contract is:
Voidable. The minor can disaffirm it (Family Code 6710).
Editing check. What is California's test for incapacitation by alcohol?
Understanding "the fact, nature, or extent of the sexual activity" (Ed. Code 67386(a)(4)(B)).
Read next
Ed. Code 67386(a)(2) and (a)(4), in your local copy. Together they are seven sentences, and they contain the whole intoxication-versus-incapacitation rule plus the duty to take reasonable steps.
Reference: Glossary, now with capacity terms.
Take this lesson home
Scan the code or type the link to work through the lesson and its quiz at your own pace.
Your answers are saved only in this browser, so you can pick up where you left off.