Consent: vocabulary and conceptsLesson 3about 15 minutes

Pressure words

"Coerced" is the umbrella word. Under it sit more precise terms, and each names a different way of getting a yes that does not count. This lesson sorts them by how the pressure works, so you can choose the exact word.

Warm-up

Score: 0 / 0 · 0 of 3 answered

Questions from Lessons 1 and 2. Answer from memory.

  1. Which standard puts the duty on each person to make sure the other agreed?

  2. A threat produces the yes. Which of the five tests fails?

  3. "She was willing" describes a state of mind. Which word describes something communicated?

Five ways pressure works

MechanismTermsTest it fails
Physicalforce, violence, restraintVoluntary
Threatduress, menace, extortionVoluntary
Positionundue influence, abuse of authorityVoluntary
Wearing downsexual coercion, coercive controlVoluntary
Deceptionfraud, impersonation, mistakeInformed

Physical

California's rape statute lists acts "accomplished against a person's will by means of force, violence, duress, menace, or fear of immediate and unlawful bodily injury" (Penal Code 261(a)(2)). Force is the oldest and clearest category. It is the whole of the Force standard from Lesson 2.

Threat

Here the vocabulary gets tricky. The same word means different things in different California codes.

TermCivil Code (contracts)Penal Code 261 (rape)
DuressUnlawful confinement of a person or their family, or detention of their property (Civ. 1569)"A direct or implied threat of force, violence, danger, or retribution sufficient to coerce a reasonable person of ordinary susceptibilities" (PC 261(b))
MenaceA threat of duress, of violent injury, or "of injury to the character" of the person (Civ. 1570)"Any threat, declaration, or act that shows an intention to inflict an injury upon another" (PC 261(b))

Penal Code 261(b) also says the victim's age and relationship to the defendant are factors in judging duress. Penal Code 261 separately names threats to retaliate with kidnapping, serious injury, or death, and threats to use "the authority of a public official to incarcerate, arrest, or deport" (PC 261(a)(6)-(7)). The Model Penal Code groups these under extortion: threats to accuse someone of a crime, to use official power, or any threat that would make "someone of ordinary resolution" submit (MPC 213.4).

Position

Undue influence is using "a confidence" or "real or apparent authority" over someone "for the purpose of obtaining an unfair advantage" (Civil Code 1575). No threat is needed. The trust or authority does the work.

Wearing down

The US Office on Women's Health defines sexual coercion as "unwanted sexual activity that happens when you are pressured, tricked, threatened, or forced in a nonphysical way." Its examples include being worn down by repeated asking and threats to end the relationship (womenshealth.gov). Many of these acts are not crimes on their own. They still fail the Voluntary test.

Coercive control describes a pattern, not a single act. California defines it as "a pattern of behavior that in purpose or effect unreasonably interferes with a person's free will and personal liberty." The examples include isolating the person from friends and family, depriving them of necessities, monitoring their movements, communications, or finances, and reproductive coercion (Family Code 6320(c), added in 2020). It appears in domestic violence restraining-order law, not the criminal code.

Deception

Under Civil Code 1567, fraud and mistake make contract consent "not real." In sexual assault law the list is narrower. California covers a person who "submits under the belief that the person committing the act is someone known to the victim other than the accused" (PC 261(a)(5)), which is impersonation. The Model Penal Code covers false medical purpose and impersonation of someone "personally known" (MPC 213.5). Most other lies about the act, such as a false promise of commitment, fail the Informed test without being crimes.

For editing. When a manuscript says "coerced," ask two questions. Was it one act or a pattern? Was the lever force, a threat, a position, persistence, or a lie? The answers point to the precise word. If the text uses "duress" or "menace," check whether the civil or the criminal meaning is intended.

Scenarios

relational

Over two years, Dana's husband takes over the bank account, reads her texts, and discourages her from seeing her sister.

Coercive control. No single act may look serious. The pattern is what the definition targets.

relational

Chris asks for sex six times in one evening. Each time Jamie says not tonight. On the seventh, Jamie says "fine."

Sexual coercion by wearing down. The "fine" is acquiescence. It is not a voluntary yes.

legal

A man threatens to call immigration on his partner unless she complies.

Threat of official authority. PC 261(a)(7) names threats "to incarcerate, arrest, or deport." In the coercive-control list, Family Code 6320(c)(4) names threats "based on actual or suspected immigration status."

Saying it in a real conversation

SituationSay
Asking without pressure"I'd like to. I'm also completely fine if you don't."
After a no"Got it. I won't ask again tonight."
Holding your own no"I've answered. Asking again won't change it."
Naming a pattern"When you check my phone, I don't feel free to say no to you."

These phrasings are suggestions.

Quiz

Score: 0 / 0 · 0 of 8 answered

Which term fits most precisely?

  1. Over months, a partner controls the money, tracks her phone, and cuts off her friends.

  2. One partner asks again and again all evening until the other gives in.

  3. In a dark room, someone pretends to be the victim's boyfriend.

  4. "Sign the contract or I'll tell everyone you're a fraud."

  5. A trusted financial advisor steers an elderly client into signing over her savings.

  6. In California rape law, this term means an implied threat of retribution strong enough to coerce a reasonable person, judged partly by the victim's age and relationship to the defendant.

  7. Editing check. Which statement is accurate?

  8. Editing check. A character's husband has tracked her location and controlled her bank account for years. Which phrase is most precise?

Office on Women's Health: Sexual coercion. It is short, plain, and full of examples that are useful for spotting coercion in a manuscript.

Reference: Glossary, now with a section on pressure words.

Your answers are saved only in this browser, so you can pick up where you left off.