Consent: vocabulary and conceptsLesson 1about 12 minutes
The five tests of valid consent
A "yes" counts as consent only if it passes five tests. The same tests apply to a kiss and to a contract. Once you know them, you can say exactly what went wrong in a scenario, or in a manuscript sentence.
The five tests
| Test | Question to ask | Fails when |
|---|---|---|
| Capacity | Is this person able to consent at all? | Under the age of consent, asleep, unconscious, incapacitated by drugs or alcohol, unable to communicate |
| Voluntary | Is the choice free? | Force, threats, pressure, abuse of trust or authority |
| Informed | Do they know what they are agreeing to? | Lies or concealment about the act or its terms |
| Expressed | Did they actually communicate yes? | Silence, no resistance, or an assumption from the relationship is treated as yes |
| Specific | Does the yes cover this act, now? | A yes to one thing is stretched to another, or a yes is not withdrawn when it was taken back |
The five-test grouping is this course's own frame. Each test comes from the sources below.
Where each test comes from
California's campus law gives the clearest definition. Education Code 67386 says affirmative consent is an "affirmative, conscious, and voluntary agreement to engage in sexual activity." It continues:
Lack of protest or resistance does not mean consent, nor does silence mean consent. Affirmative consent must be ongoing throughout a sexual activity and can be revoked at any time. The existence of a dating relationship between the persons involved, or the fact of past sexual relations between them, should never by itself be assumed to be an indicator of consent.
That passage covers Voluntary, Expressed, and Specific. The same statute lists when a person is unable to consent: asleep or unconscious, incapacitated by drugs, alcohol, or medication "so that the complainant could not understand the fact, nature, or extent of the sexual activity," or unable to communicate due to a mental or physical condition. That is Capacity.
California's criminal code adds Informed. Penal Code 261.6 defines consent as "positive cooperation in act or attitude pursuant to an exercise of free will," and says the person must "have knowledge of the nature of the act." It also says a dating or marital relationship is not enough to constitute consent. The age of consent in California is 18 (Penal Code 261.5).
Contract law uses the same tests in different words. Civil Code 1565 says consent to a contract must be "free," "mutual," and "communicated." Under Civil Code 1567, consent is "not real or free" when obtained through duress, menace, fraud, undue influence, or mistake. Duress and menace are force and threats. Undue influence is abuse of trust or authority. All three fail Voluntary. Fraud and mistake fail Informed.
Planned Parenthood's plain-language version is FRIES: Freely given, Reversible, Informed, Enthusiastic, Specific. FRIES maps onto the five tests, with one addition. Enthusiastic is a higher bar than the law sets. Lesson 2 covers that gap.
Scenarios
Sam and Alex have been together five years. Alex is exhausted and lies still. Sam takes the stillness as fine because "we always do this on Fridays."
Fails Expressed. Stillness is "lack of protest," and routine is "past sexual relations." The statute rules out both as consent.
A landlord tells a tenant to sign a lease change today or the landlord will tell the tenant's employer the tenant is a thief.
Fails Voluntary. This is menace, which Civil Code 1570 defines to include a threat "of injury to the character" of the person.
Jordan agrees to go back to Riley's place "to keep talking." Riley later says, "You came home with me, so you knew what this was."
Fails Specific. A yes to one thing is not a yes to another. FRIES uses nearly this example.
Saying it in a real conversation
These phrasings are suggestions. Each one checks one test.
| Test | Ask or say |
|---|---|
| Capacity | "You've had a lot tonight. Let's wait until morning." |
| Voluntary | "No is a completely fine answer. Nothing changes between us." |
| Informed | "Before you decide, here's what I'm actually asking." |
| Expressed | "I want to hear it from you. Is this a yes?" |
| Specific | "Still good?" and, for yourself, "I'm good with this, not that." |
Quiz
Score: 0 / 0 · 0 of 7 answered
Which test fails? Pick the one that fails most clearly.
Two people agree to make out. One assumes that agreement covers sex.
Specific. A yes covers the act agreed to, not the next one.
A buyer signs after the seller threatens to spread rumors that the buyer is a cheat.
Voluntary. This is menace: a threat of injury to character (Civil Code 1570).
Someone agrees to sex only with a condom. The partner removes it without saying so.
Informed. The yes was given to a different act than the one that happened. FRIES uses this exact example.
A person who cannot stand up without help slurs "sure."
Capacity. The legal question is not whether they drank but whether they could "understand the fact, nature, or extent of the sexual activity" (Education Code 67386(a)(4)(B)). Someone this impaired likely cannot, so the "sure" does not count.
A spouse never asks, because "we're married." The other spouse says nothing.
Expressed. Silence is not consent, and marriage alone does not constitute consent (Penal Code 261.6).
A caregiver who manages an elderly man's money presses him to sign his house over to her.
Voluntary. This is undue influence: using a position of trust to gain an unfair advantage (Civil Code 1575).
Editing check. Which sentence describes consent under California's affirmative standard?
The second. The first treats silence as consent, and the third treats a relationship as consent. The fourth is subtler. The 2022 Model Penal Code allows consent "inferred from behavior," but the affirmative standard does not rely on inference. Lesson 2 covers this split (ALI Adviser).
Read next
California Education Code 67386. It is one page long and the most precise consent definition you will quote. If the site blocks you, read the local copy.
Reference: Glossary, which grows with each lesson.
Take this lesson home
Scan the code or type the link to work through the lesson and its quiz at your own pace.
buildswithmorgan.com/learn/consent/five-tests-of-valid-consent/
Your answers are saved only in this browser, so you can pick up where you left off.