Pitot-static: which instrument is lying?Lesson 2about 9 minutes

The blocked static port

A frozen altimeter is obvious. The airspeed error that comes with it is not, and on final approach it points you the wrong way.

Warm-up

Score: 0 / 0 · 0 of 2 answered

Before anything new. Answer without opening lesson 0001.

  1. The airspeed indicator is misbehaving. The altimeter and VSI both agree with what you see outside. Which side of the system failed?

  2. Which pressure source do all three pitot-static instruments share?

The situation this solves

You are on a long descent into your home field. The altimeter has stopped moving. You notice, you file it away, and you keep flying, because the airplane is fine and you are busy. What you have not noticed is that the airspeed indicator is now reading roughly thirty knots faster than you are actually going, and the error is growing every hundred feet you descend.

So you see 90 knots on short final and think you are fast. You raise the nose. You are actually at 60 and slowing.

That is the accident this lesson is meant to prevent. The frozen altimeter is the warning. The airspeed error is the thing that hurts you.

Why the airspeed indicator goes wrong at all

It should not be obvious. The pitot tube is clear, ram air is arriving normally, and the airspeed indicator is the one instrument that has a working input. But it does not display a pressure. It displays a subtraction.

What the ASI actually computes

indicated airspeed  ←  pitot pressure − static pressure

The pitot side is live and correct. The static side is a sealed sample of the air from wherever you were when the port plugged. You are subtracting a memory.

From there it falls out in one step. Air pressure rises as you descend.

  • Descend below the blockage altitude. Ram pressure is now built on top of a higher ambient pressure, but you are still subtracting the old, lower sample. You subtract too little. Airspeed reads high.
  • Climb above it. Ambient pressure has fallen, but you are still subtracting the old, higher sample. You subtract too much. Airspeed reads low.

The altimeter and VSI need no derivation. The altimeter reads the static pressure directly, so a frozen sample means a frozen altitude. The VSI reads the rate of change of static pressure, and a sealed line has no rate of change, so it settles to zero and stays there. Source: FAA PHAK, Chapter 8.

How big is the error?

Bigger and faster than most people expect, and this is the part worth feeling rather than reading. The simulator below computes indications from the standard atmosphere, so the numbers are the real ones.

The static port is sealed at 5,000 feet with the airplane truly flying 100 knots. Drag the airplane away from that altitude and watch the airspeed needle.

Roughly a thousand feet of altitude is worth about an inch of mercury of pressure. The ram pressure at 100 knots is worth about half that. So a few hundred feet either side of the blockage is enough to move the airspeed needle further than any normal flight condition ever would. There is no gentle version of this failure.

The fix: alternate static source

In most 172s a knob on the lower panel, marked ALTERNATE STATIC AIR, opens the static line to the cabin instead of the outside port. Pull it and all three instruments come back.

They come back slightly wrong, and in a predictable direction. Air moving over the fuselage, plus leakage around doors and windows, holds the cabin at a marginally lower pressure than the outside air. A lower static pressure means a smaller number to subtract, and a higher altitude on the altimeter's scale.

On alternate static

Everything reads high. Altimeter high, airspeed high, and a brief false climb indication on the VSI at the moment you pull the knob.

Try the third button in the simulator above and compare it against the truth line.

Two practical consequences. Cabin vents and windows change the cabin pressure, so the POH correction only holds in the configuration the POH specifies. And the correction values differ between 172 models, so the number that matters is the one in the handbook for the tail number you are flying, not one from the internet.

What to carry away

The trapped static pressure is a memory of an altitude. Fly below that memory and the airspeed reads high. Fly above it and the airspeed reads low. Pull the alternate static source and everything reads a little high.

The dangerous case is the descent, because a high airspeed reading invites you to slow down at exactly the moment you cannot afford to.

Quiz

Score: 0 / 0 · 0 of 5 answered

  1. Your static port plugs at 6,000 ft. You descend to 4,000 ft holding a genuine 90 knots. What does the airspeed indicator show?

  2. Same blockage at 6,000 ft. You climb to 8,000 ft at a genuine 90 knots. What does the airspeed indicator show?

  3. Why does the VSI settle on zero when the static port blocks, rather than freezing at whatever rate it was showing?

  4. You pull the alternate static source. Which way do the indications move?

  5. Your altimeter is frozen but the airspeed still looks completely reasonable. What is the most likely explanation?

Your answers are saved only in this browser, so you can pick up where you left off.