Pitot-static: which instrument is lying?Lesson 3about 9 minutes

The blocked pitot tube

One small hole decides whether the airspeed indicator dies loudly or lies quietly. The quiet version is the one that has killed people.

Warm-up

Score: 0 / 0 · 0 of 3 answered

  1. Static port blocked. You descend below the blockage altitude at a steady true airspeed. Which way does the airspeed indicator err?

  2. Only the airspeed indicator is misbehaving. What does that tell you?

  3. You pull the alternate static source. Which way do the indications move?

The hole you have never looked at

The pitot tube has two openings. The ram inlet at the front is the one you check. There is a second, much smaller hole underneath, near the base: the drain hole. It exists so that water entering the tube runs out instead of collecting in the line.

That drain hole is the entire lesson. Whether it is open or blocked decides which of two completely different failures you get.

Two cases, one difference

Inlet blocked, drain open. The pitot line vents to ambient pressure through the drain. Both sides of the airspeed diaphragm now see the same pressure, so the needle goes to zero and stays there.

Inlet and drain both blocked. The line traps a pressure sample. The airspeed indicator becomes an altimeter: it reads high in a climb and low in a descent.

Why case two behaves like an altimeter

Same subtraction as lesson 0002, with the roles swapped.

indicated airspeed  ←  pitot pressure − static pressure

Last time the static side was frozen and the pitot side was live. Now the pitot side is frozen at whatever total pressure existed when it sealed, and the static side is live and falling as you climb. Subtracting a shrinking number from a fixed one gives a growing result. The needle rises.

Which is exactly the mechanism inside an altimeter: a sealed pressure sample compared against ambient. The instrument has not broken. It is doing its job correctly on bad input.

Feel it

The pitot tube seals at 5,000 feet with the airplane genuinely flying 100 knots. Try both failure cases, then drag the altitude. Watch what the altimeter and VSI do while the airspeed misbehaves.

Note what does not happen. The altimeter and VSI stay honest in both cases, because nothing touched the static line. That is the lesson 0001 rule showing up as an observation you can make in half a second.

The accident case

Case two on departure is the dangerous one. You rotate, you climb, and the airspeed indicator climbs with you. Everything looks not just normal but healthy, so you keep pitching to hold the number the needle is showing. The number is a lie that grows with altitude, and holding it means pitching up into a stall.

This is Birgenair Flight 301, a Boeing 757 that crashed after departing Puerto Plata in February 1996, killing all 189 aboard. The airplane had sat for 25 days with uncovered pitot tubes and mud dauber wasps nested in one. The captain noticed his airspeed indication was wrong during the takeoff roll and continued anyway. Climbing through the night, his indicator read 350 knots and rising while the airplane was actually doing 220 and slowing. The autopilot obediently pitched up. Different airplane, identical physics, and the same decision point you get on the takeoff roll.

What you actually do

  1. Pitot heat on. Ice is the blockage that forms in flight, and it blocks both holes, which makes it case two. Heat is the only in-flight fix and it is the only cause heat can fix. It will not clear a wasp nest.
  2. Fly pitch and power. A known attitude and a known power setting produce a known airspeed. This works regardless of which failure you have, and it works before you have finished diagnosing it.
  3. Cross-check. GPS groundspeed, corrected roughly for wind, will tell you within a few seconds whether 350 knots is plausible.
  4. Do not chase the needle. The airplane is telling you the truth through attitude, sound, and control feel. The instrument is one input and it is the one under suspicion.

The last free catch

"Airspeed alive" during the takeoff roll. If the needle has not moved by the time you would normally see 40 knots, abort. You are on the ground, you have runway ahead, and the decision costs nothing.

This is the moment the Birgenair captain reached and did not take.

The matrix is now complete

FailureAirspeedAltimeterVSI
Pitot inlet blocked, drain openZeroNormalNormal
Pitot inlet and drain blockedHigh in climb, low in descentNormalNormal
Static port blockedLow in climb, high in descentFrozenZero

The two airspeed rows point in opposite directions, which is the thing most people get backwards under pressure. You do not have to memorise which is which. Ask what is frozen and what is live, then do the subtraction.

Quiz

Score: 0 / 0 · 0 of 5 answered

  1. A wasp nest plugs the ram inlet on the ground but the drain hole stays clear. What does the airspeed indicator do during the takeoff roll?

  2. Ice seals both the ram inlet and the drain hole at 3,000 ft. You climb to 7,000 ft holding a genuine 100 knots. What do you see?

  3. With the pitot tube fully blocked, what happens to the altimeter and VSI?

  4. You turn on pitot heat and the airspeed indication comes back. What was the blockage almost certainly caused by?

  5. Airspeed reads low in a climb and high in a descent, while the altimeter is frozen. Which line is blocked?

Your answers are saved only in this browser, so you can pick up where you left off.