Rubik's Cube: a solve that staysLesson 8about 13 minutes

Placing the top corners

Do, do something else, undo, undo — and three corners move.

Every corner into the corner it belongs in, however twisted it lands. This is the last positioning step of the solve; after it, nothing is in the wrong place and the only thing left is twist. It is also the lesson where the second piece of machinery arrives. Lesson 6 gave you the conjugate — wrap, act, unwrap. This one gives you the commutator.

Thirty seconds, from memory

Which three edges does R U R' U R U2 R' move, and which way round? And what makes a hold ready in that step?

Say both out loud first, then check

Left → right → back → left; the front edge sits it out. A hold is ready when exactly one edge matches its centre and that edge is at the front.

1. Position now, twist later

Split the corner problem the way you split the edge problem. There are two questions about any corner — is it in the right place and is it the right way round — and this lesson answers only the first. A corner sitting in its own corner with its yellow sticker facing sideways is a win here. Do not straighten it. Lesson 9 does that, and it does it to all of them at once.

A corner is home when its three colours match the three centres it touches, in any order. Yellow-red-green belongs in the corner where the yellow, red and green centres meet — whichever of its stickers happens to be on top.

Cube in hand

Hold a cube with the top edges placed and look at one top corner. Name its three colours, then point at the corner where those three centres meet. That is the question you will be asking four times in this step, and it is the only question.

One thing changed quietly. Until now, U was free — the top could be turned to any of four positions and nothing was lost. The edges are placed now, so a U turn breaks them. From here to the end of the solve, the only way to change which corner is at the front is y: turn the whole cube.

2. The commutator

Two sequences commute if doing them in either order gives the same result. Most pairs of cube moves don’t. A commutator, written [A, B], is the sequence

A  ·  B  ·  A'  ·  B'

— do, do something else, undo, undo. If A and B touched completely separate pieces, the undos would cancel the dos exactly and the cube would come back unchanged. So whatever does change is precisely the interference between them: the commutator measures the amount by which two moves fail to commute.1

That is why commutators are the workhorse of every solve past the first layer. Arrange for A and B to overlap in exactly one piece, and the result is a three-cycle: everything they disturbed goes back, except for the one piece they fought over, which comes out somewhere new.

You have already met its sibling. A conjugate is A B A' — wrap, act, unwrap — and that was F R U R' U' F' in Lesson 6. A commutator is A B A' B'. One undo, or two.

3. The sequence

U R U'  ·  L'  ·  U R' U'  ·  L

Eight moves, and you are holding two things, not eight: A = U R U' and B = L'. Then A B A' B'. Note that A is itself a conjugate — a setup turn, an R, and its undo — so the whole algorithm is one structure nested inside another, which is exactly why it can be rebuilt from memory rather than recited.

PartWhat it does
A = U R U' Parks the back-left top corner down in the bottom layer, out of harm’s way
B = L' Turns the left layer while that corner is away, changing what waits in the empty seat
A' = U R' U' Brings the parked corner back up — into a different seat than it left
B' = L Puts the left layer back. Everything it moved is restored except the one contested corner

Every beginner tutorial gives this exact string for this exact step.2 Most present it as eight letters to memorise. It is four moves and their undos, and the community name for it — Niklas — is a name for the commutator shape itself.3

4. What it actually does

Measured against the cube model behind this page’s simulator:

  • Three top corners ride a ring: back-left → front-left → back-right → back-left. Positions only.
  • The front-right corner never moves. Same handle as the edge step: you choose the exempt piece by choosing what to hold at the front right.
  • No edge moves at all. Zero edges displaced, zero flipped, in 20,000 applications — so the cross and the placed edges are safe.
  • The first two layers never move. Also zero in 20,000.
  • The three travelling corners arrive twisted. Expected, and not your problem today. Judge only whether each corner is in its own corner.

The order of the whole sequence is 3: run it three times from any position and you are exactly back where you started, twists included. That is the fact behind the rule below — running it twice sends the ring round the other way.

5. The rule

Yellow up, edges placed. Then:

  1. Find a corner that is already home — its three colours matching the three centres it touches, twist ignored. There will be exactly one, or none.
  2. Turn the whole cube with y until that corner is at the front right. It now sits the cycle out.
  3. Look at the corner that belongs at the front left. If it is sitting at the back left, run the sequence once. If it is at the back right, run it twice — same hold, no rotation between.

When no corner is home. Two pairs need to trade. If two of them trade with each other along one side, turn the cube so that pair is the right-hand pair — front right and back right — and run it once. If instead every corner needs to cross the cube diagonally, any hold will do; run it once. Either way you land in the ordinary case above, one corner home, and finish from there.

Following exactly that, 20,000 of 20,000 random positions ended with all four corners home, in at most two applications: 6% needed none, 30% one, 64% two. Zero failures, zero broken edges, zero broken layers. Held the wrong way in the no-corner-home case, the same positions cost three applications instead of two — it still works, it just takes longer.

Cube in hand

From a finished cube, run U R U' L' U R' U' L once and watch only the top corners: the front-right one is untouched, the other three have moved round and come back twisted. Run it twice more and the cube is solved again — all of it, twists included. Three is the whole cycle.

6. Once, twice, or re-hold?

Six rounds. Yellow is up, the edges are placed, the corners are not. Decide whether this hold is ready and how many applications it wants. Answering runs the sequence once so you can see where the corners went.

Retrieval — 6 rounds

7. Practise the whole step

Everything below the top corners is finished. Get all four corners home. The counter says how many are; how to hold it is yours. Remember that U is no longer free — use y.

 

 

 

Before the next lesson

  • Three solves to placed corners. Scramble, two layers, yellow cross, edges placed, corners home, stop. One step from a finished cube now.
  • Say the structure, not the letters. Once a day: “park a corner with U R U', turn the left layer, bring it back, put the left layer back.” Four ideas, eight moves.
  • Read: the Speedsolving wiki on commutators — five minutes. It is the single idea that explains the most cube algorithms per minute spent, and everything past the beginner method is built on it.
  • Keep: the Top Corners card. After a gap, read that, not this.
  • The cube stays out. Still the instruction that matters most.

Sources

  1. Speedsolving wiki, Commutator — A B A' B', and why overlapping in one piece gives a three-cycle.
  2. Ruwix, Position Yellow Corners — the beginner presentation of this step and the same eight moves.
  3. Speedsolving wiki, Niklas — the community name for this commutator.
  4. Jaap Scherphuis, Useful Mathematics — permutation parity, and why three-cycles are the smallest safe tool.
  5. J Perm, How to Solve the 3x3 — the same step, taught as “position the last layer corners”.

Quiz

Score: 0 / 0 · 0 of 5 answered

Answer from memory, then check.

  1. When is a top corner home in this step?

  2. The top edges are placed. How do you change which corner is at the front now?

  3. What is a commutator?

  4. In U R U' L' U R' U' L, what are A and B?

  5. How many times must you run the sequence to bring any position back to where it started?

Next lesson: the last one. Every piece is in its place and some corners are twisted. The move that fixes it is one you already own from Lesson 4.

Your answers are saved only in this browser, so you can pick up where you left off.